Our story

A Little More Cookie started with an idea to combine a love of cookies with watercolor art. But our cookie recipe goes back a generation. Our shortbread cookie recipe comes from our founder’s uncle who to no surprise used to bake and sell his own decorated cookies. Fast forward 20 years, and now we’re putting our own decorative spin on things.

Founded by a former camp director turned cookie decorator, our cookies bring the taste of buttery shortbread with a pop of memorable detail. Whether your event is a wedding, vow renewal, bridal shower, or high tea, we’re the perfect addition to elevate your already exquisite event.

If you’re wondering what your dessert table, guest favors, or coffee bar still needs, we’re sure you’ll agree its a little more…cookie.

  • We recommend ordering as far in advance of your event as possible, but require a minimum of 2 weeks notice. A rush fee of $50 may be added to orders placed less than 2 weeks in advance.

  • A minimum order of 1 dozen cookies is required. We are unable to sell individual cookies at this time.

  • Our cookies are made with butter, all purpose flour, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, salt, meringue powder, lemon juice, water, and food coloring (for decoration).

    We now offer a Gluten Free Cookie option! See “Gluten Free Cookie Details” for more information.

  • We’re excited to offer a Gluten-Free Cookie option now! We know that gluten sensitivities can vary so here’s what you should know:

    Our Gluten-Free Cookies are made to ensure the same flavor and look as our regular cookies just with all gluten-free ingredients!

    Ingredients: Butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavorings), Gluten-Free Flour (white rice flour, brown rice flour, tapioca starch, potato starch, potato flour, xanthan gum, pectin), Powdered Sugar (sugar, cornstarch), Vanilla Extract (vanilla bean extractive in purified water, 10% alcohol, vanillin), Salt, Meringue Powder (corn starch, egg whites, sugar, gum arabic, calcium sulphate, citric acid, cream of tartar [potassium acid tartrate,] artificial flavor, silicon dioxide), Lemon Juice, Food Colorings, Contains: milk, egg

    Gluten-Free Cookies are made in a kitchen that may also process common food allergens. They are not made in a dedicated gluten free kitchen.

  • Cookies are heat-sealed in individual packages and placed in a bakery box for easy transport and delivery.

  • Yes, we offer shipping for cookies within the state of Illinois! We are unable to ship cookies across state lines at this time. Delivery may be available depending on your location. Pick-Up is also available.

    We can ship paper goods anywhere within the U.S.!

  • Cookies are good for up to 4 weeks after you receive them.

    We recommend storing unopened cookies in their packages at room temperature.

  • All cookies arrive in heat-sealed packages for freshness. They’re best stored at room temperature in the sealed bags & enjoyed within 4 weeks.

    Note: Cookies can be frozen for future enjoyment! To freeze, place the sealed cookie into a sealed container (i.e. ziploc bag or tupperware) and freeze up to 3 months. Thaw to room temperature in sealed bag before enjoying.

  • Orders are accepted on a first come, first serve basis. If we are able to accommodate your last minute order, we will! A $50 Rush Order Fee will apply to orders placed less than 2 weeks in advance.

    Inquire about last minute orders by emailing alittlemorecookie@gmail.com‍ ‍or fillign out the Contact Form on our website.

Frequently Asked Questions

We’d love to hear from you —

Ready to add A Little More Cookie to your next event?
Start your order→